McAlvany ICA Reviews, Complaints & Ratings 2024

Looking for a reliable precious metals investment company? Is McAlvany ICA a legit company or a scam? Are there any online McAlvany ICA reviews or complaints from customers? Let’s find out now.

What Is McAlvany ICA?

McAlvany ICA Reviews

McAlvany ICA, also known as International Collectors Associates, is a family business founded in 1972 by Don S. McAlvany. Currently, McAlvany ICA is managed by Don’s son, David S. McAlvany.

McAlvany ICA is one of the industry’s top precious metals dealers and is headquartered in Durango, Colorado. The company is committed to providing free customer education, and its team of specialists is ready to assist you. They provide free insightful information about precious metals and current market news on their website.

Does McAlvany ICA Offer Gold & Silver IRAs?

The company does offer IRAs, but their custodians and depository institutions are not disclosed. This makes it difficult for us to estimate their IRA fees and costs. We recommend Goldco if you are searching for a trustworthy and transparent gold and silver IRA provider.

McAlvany ICA Review Summary


Durango, Colorado


166 Turner Dr

Durango, CO 81303-7975

Year Founded:



Don S. McAlvany (Founder), David S. McAlvany (President)



[usr 3]

Click Here To Learn About Our #1 Rated Precious Metals IRA Firm>

McAlvany ICA Products & Services

McAlvany ICA products

They primarily sell IRA-approved gold, silver, and platinum coins and bars, as well as collectible coins. McAlvany ICA does not offer palladium products at this time. Here are some of their products.


  • 1 Kilo Gold Bar
  • 1-oz Gold Bar
  • 1-oz gold Canadian Maple Leaf
  • 1-oz Gold American Eagle
  • 1-oz gold South African Krugerrand
  • $20 Saint-Gaudens Gold Double Eagle MS Series
  • Dutch 10 Guilder
  • MS60 British Sovereigns


  • 1-oz Silver Bar
  • 1000-oz Silver Bar
  • 100-oz Silver Bar
  • 10-oz Silver Bar
  • 1-oz Silver Round
  • 1-oz Silver Canadian Maple Leaf
  • 1-oz Silver American Eagle
  • Silver Peace Dollar
  • 90% Junk Silver


Currently, McAlvany ICA only offers 1-oz platinum bars.

How to Get Started

To place an order, you must contact McAlvany ICA by phone or email and seek advice from their consultants. You may also submit a request using their online ordering system, which allows you to select a selection of your desired products. A sales representative will contact you and assist you with the transaction once your request has been received.

Pros of McAlvany ICA

  • Has Been In Business for Half a Century

Since 1972, McAlvany ICA has been in operation. Consequently, they are one of the few businesses with a proven track record.

  • Free Customer Education

In the resources section of their website, you will find free guides and market news. In addition, their team of highly experienced advisors is available to guide you and assist you in building a solid investment portfolio.

  • Quality Products

David and his employees have a multitude of knowledge regarding precious metals. The majority of their products are selected with attention to ensure their superior quality.

Cons of McAlvany ICA

  • Lacks Customer Reviews and Ratings

The majority of online consumer protection and review websites lack McAlvany ICA reviews. This is quite startling considering how long they have been in business.

  • Lacks Transparency

There is no information regarding the company’s IRA custodians or storage providers. Furthermore, there is no pricing or fee information on their website.

  • Limited Selection of Products

The company does not provide palladium coins and bars. In addition, they have fewer coins and bars in stock than leading precious metals companies.

Accreditation, Reputation & Complaints

Customer reviews of McAlvany ICA

McAlvany ICA is BBB-accredited and holds an A+ rating despite having no user reviews and 2 complaints on the platform. Again, they do not have any reviews on BCA, Trustlink, Trustpilot, or Yelp.

  • BBB: A+ Rating, 0 reviews (View Details)
  • BCA: Not Listed
  • Trustlink: Not Listed
  • Trustpilot: Not Listed
  • Yelp: Not Listed

Is McAlvany ICA Legit?

McAlvany ICA is a legitimate business based on its extensive history and track record of success. They have been in operation for fifty years.

Alternatives to McAlvany ICA 

McAlvany ICA Reviews Conclusion

McAlvany ICA is a family-owned precious metals dealer based in Durango, Colorado. It is one of the oldest in the industry having been formed in 1982. McAlvany ICA offers free customer education and quality products, but they lack transparency as well as customer ratings and reviews. In addition, its collection of coins and bars is smaller than that of its competitors.

Verified by MonsterInsights