Manhattan Coin Shop Reviews & Ratings 2024

Is Manhattan Coin Shop the finest place to purchase or sell precious metals, or should you look elsewhere? How are their online customer reviews? In this review of Manhattan Coin Shop, you will learn everything you need to know about this renowned coin dealer.

What Is Manhattan Coin Shop?

Manhattan Coin Shop Reviews

Manhattan Coin Shop is a coin dealer situated in New York City’s Manhattan neighborhood. The company buys and sells coins and is renowned for its enormous collection, which is replenished daily. In addition to collectible coins, Manhattan Coin Shop offers IRA-eligible bullion, including Gold American Eagles, Maple Leafs, and Kilo gold bars.

If you are interested in selling your coins, Manhattan Coin Shop offers excellent prices. They claim to be the most lucrative coin dealer in New York City and the entire globe.

Manhattan Coin Shop Review Summary


New York City, New York


30 W 47th St #846, New York, NY 10036, United States

Year Founded:






[usr 3.6]

Click Here To See Our Top-rated Gold & Silver IRA Provider>

Manhattan Coin Shop Products & Services

The Manhattan Coin Shop carries an extensive variety of bullion coins and bars, as well as rare coins. Their most popular coins include the American Gold Eagle, the Canadian Gold Maple Leaf, and the South African Krugerrand. In stock are also 1oz and Kilo PAMP Suisse gold bars. As the company has no partnerships with IRA custodians, it is unable to offer gold and silver IRA services.

Interested in opening a Gold IRA? This esteemed Gold IRA provider is recommended by us.

How to Get Started

Unlike other online retailers, Manhattan Coin Shop’s website does not permit account creation. Their website primarily contains information about their products and services, as well as contact details. To place an order, you must fill out a contact form on their website or give them a call; they will then let you know if the desired item is in stock.

Manhattan Coin Shop Costs & Fees

Surprisingly, the company does not list the prices of all available products. To find out the buying or selling price of each coin plus shipping costs, you must contact them by phone or via their online contact form.

Pros of Manhattan Coin Shop

  • High-Quality Products

The majority of their coins are of superior quality, with the vast majority meeting IRS requirements for IRA eligibility.

  • Wide Selection of Coins

They have an extensive selection of bullion coins and bars as well as collectibles.

Cons of Manhattan Coin Shop

  • Lacks Reviews

Almost all major online review websites lack client reviews and ratings for the company. Additionally, they are not accredited by the Better Business Bureau.

  • You Can’t Order Online

Because Manhattan Coin Shop lacks an e-commerce platform, you cannot place orders online on your own. You must contact them or send them an email to place an order.

  • No IRA Services

Manhattan Coin Shop is unable to provide the highly sought-after gold and silver IRA services due to their lack of partnerships with reputable IRA custodians.

Manhattan Coin Shop Reviews & Ratings

Other than Google My Business, where they have a rating of 3.9 out of 5 stars, all major online review websites lack reviews for Manhattan Coin Shop. They are not listed or rated on BBB, BCA Trustlink, Trustpilot, Yelp, and other leading consumer protection websites.

Is Manhattan Coin Shop Legit?

Is it legit or a scam? Manhattan Coin Shop is a legit coin dealer. It is among the most reputable coin dealers in New York City.

Manhattan Coin Shop Alternatives


Manhattan Coin Shop is a coin dealer located in New York City that stocks a vast selection of bullion coins and bars. The majority of the company’s high-quality products are eligible for IRA investment.

Unfortunately, Manhattan Coin Shop does not provide IRA services. In addition, they lack reviews and accreditation from reputable online review sites, such as the Better Business Bureau and Trustlink. In addition, the company does not accept online orders; you must call or send an email to inquire.

Verified by MonsterInsights