Important Update: During our research for this PMJ Coins review, we found indications that PMJ Coins may no longer be operating. According to Birdeye listings, the business appears to be permanently closed. Additionally, attempts to access the company’s official website were unsuccessful at the time of writing. Prospective buyers should independently verify the company’s current operating status before conducting any transactions.
Introduction
If you’re searching for a PMJ Coins review, you’re likely wondering whether this New York-based coin dealer is a trustworthy place to buy rare coins, precious metals, or numismatic collectibles.
PMJ Coins built a reputation as a specialized coin dealer serving both wholesale and retail collectors. The company offered certified gold and silver coins, grading submission services through leading authentication agencies, and estate collection purchasing. However, recent reports suggesting that the business may have permanently closed have raised questions among collectors and investors.
In this comprehensive PMJ Coins review, we’ll examine the company’s history, ownership, products, fees, customer feedback, pros and cons, and overall reputation to help determine whether PMJ Coins was a legitimate dealer and whether there are better alternatives available today.
What Is PMJ Coins?
PMJ Coins was a specialized numismatic dealer and rare coin shop based in New York. The company initially operated as a wholesale supplier serving other coin dealers before expanding into direct retail sales for collectors and investors.
The firm focused primarily on certified U.S. gold and silver coins, rare numismatic pieces, and collectible currency. Over the years, PMJ Coins developed relationships with major grading organizations and became known for offering professionally authenticated coins.
Business Details
| Detail | Information |
|---|---|
| Company Name | PMJ Coins & Collectibles |
| Industry | Rare Coins & Numismatics |
| Location | New Hyde Park, New York |
| Founded | Wholesale origins before retail expansion |
| Specialty | Certified U.S. Coins & Precious Metals |
| Website | pmjcoins.com (currently inaccessible) |
| Status | Appears permanently closed |
Primary Products
PMJ Coins specialized in:
- Certified gold coins
- Certified silver coins
- Morgan Silver Dollars
- Rare U.S. coinage
- Commemorative coins
- Pioneer gold coins
- Bullion products
- Estate collections
- Coin grading submissions
The company also maintained an active eBay store selling various collectibles beyond coins.
Who Owned PMJ Coins?
According to available business records, Marijo Lantier served as the owner and president of PMJ Coins.
Under her leadership, the company transitioned from a wholesale-only operation into a retail-focused business serving coin collectors directly.
Key Personnel
Marijo Lantier
- President and Owner
- Strategic business leadership
- Oversaw company growth and expansion
- Managed relationships with grading agencies
Amandeep
- Head Coin Dealer
- Daily operations manager
- Coin evaluation specialist
- Customer-facing representative
The company developed a reputation among customers for knowledgeable service and expertise in certified coinage.
PMJ Coins Products & Services
PMJ Coins offered a broad selection of products and services designed for collectors, investors, and estate sellers.
1. Certified Gold & Silver Coins
The company’s core inventory included:
- Certified gold coins
- Certified silver coins
- American Silver Eagles
- Gold commemoratives
- Investment-grade bullion
- NGC-certified coins
- PCGS-certified coins
These products appealed to both collectors and precious metals investors.
2. Rare U.S. Coinage
PMJ Coins specialized in numerous collectible U.S. coins, including:
- Morgan Silver Dollars
- Buffalo Nickels
- Half Dollars
- Early American coinage
- Key-date coins
- Rare mint varieties
Collectors often sought these pieces for both historical significance and investment potential.
3. Coin Grading Services
One of the company’s strongest offerings was assistance with professional coin grading.
PMJ Coins reportedly acted as an authorized submission center for major grading agencies, helping collectors submit coins for:
- Authentication
- Grading
- Encapsulation
- Conservation
- Re-holdering
Grading Partners
- PCGS
- NGC
- NCS
This service was particularly valuable for collectors unfamiliar with the grading submission process.
4. Coin Buying & Estate Liquidation
PMJ Coins also purchased:
- Individual rare coins
- Entire collections
- Estate holdings
- Gold jewelry
- Silver coins
- Certified numismatic assets
The company provided appraisals and direct purchase offers for sellers seeking immediate liquidity.
5. Collectibles & Hobby Products
Unlike many traditional coin dealers, PMJ Coins diversified its inventory through its eBay store.
Additional products included:
- Action figures
- Model trains
- Diecast vehicles
- Pop culture collectibles
- Hobby accessories
While this broadened its customer base, some collectors preferred dealers focused exclusively on numismatics.
PMJ Coins Pricing & Fees
PMJ Coins did not publicly disclose fixed pricing schedules.
Like most coin dealers, prices fluctuated based on:
- Precious metals spot prices
- Coin rarity
- Condition
- Certification status
- Market demand
Buying Coins
Typical pricing followed:
Bullion Coins
Retail prices generally consisted of:
Spot Price + Dealer Premium
Premiums varied depending on:
- Product availability
- Market conditions
- Coin popularity
- Order size
Rare Coins
Numismatic coins were priced individually based on:
- Grade
- Rarity
- Mint mark
- Historical significance
- Collector demand
Coin Grading Fees
Collectors using grading services could expect costs including:
| Service | Estimated Cost |
|---|---|
| Standard Grading | $22 – $300+ |
| Shipping | Varies |
| Insurance | Varies |
| Handling | Approximately $10+ |
Actual fees depended on the grading service selected and the value of submitted coins.
Selling Coins to PMJ Coins
Like most coin shops, PMJ Coins typically paid:
- Below retail value
- Near wholesale value
- Spot-based rates for bullion
- Market-based rates for collectible coins
Sellers should always compare multiple offers before liquidating valuable collections.
PMJ Coins Customer Reviews
One challenge when evaluating PMJ Coins is the relatively limited number of independent reviews available online.
Ratings Snapshot
| Platform | Rating |
|---|---|
| BBB | Not Accredited |
| Trustpilot | Not Listed |
| TrustLink | Not Listed |
| Yelp | 5/5 (1 Review) |
| Birdeye | 4.1/5 (9 Reviews) |
| Google Business | Limited Presence |
Positive Customer Feedback
Customers frequently praised:
- Fair pricing
- Industry knowledge
- Honest dealings
- Professional service
- Rare coin expertise
One reviewer stated:
“Always fair and always honest.”
Another customer referred to the business as their preferred destination for rare coins and unique bullion products.
Negative Feedback
Not all experiences were positive.
One customer reported receiving an offer lower than expected when selling coins, noting:
“I think I could have gotten more.”
This type of complaint is relatively common throughout the coin industry since dealer buy prices are typically lower than retail selling prices.
PMJ Coins Complaints
Our research found relatively few public complaints.
However, potential concerns included:
Limited Online Presence
- Few third-party reviews
- No Trustpilot profile
- No BBB accreditation
- Minimal transparency regarding operations
Single Location
- Only one physical storefront
- Limited geographic reach
- No nationwide branch network
Website Accessibility Issues
At the time of writing:
- Official website appeared inaccessible
- Business may no longer be operating
- Customer support availability remains unclear
These factors make it difficult for prospective customers to evaluate the company’s current status.
Pros of PMJ Coins
Strong Industry Credentials
✓ Authorized dealer relationships with PCGS, NGC, and NCS
✓ Experienced numismatic leadership
✓ Long-standing presence in the coin industry
Specialized Rare Coin Expertise
✓ Strong focus on certified coins
✓ Knowledgeable staff
✓ Estate purchasing services
Multiple Buying Channels
✓ Physical storefront
✓ eBay marketplace presence
✓ Wholesale and retail experience
Positive Customer Feedback
✓ Reports of fair dealing
✓ Helpful customer service
✓ Honest business practices
Cons of PMJ Coins
Business Status Uncertainty
✗ Reports suggest the company may have permanently closed
✗ Official website inaccessible
✗ Limited public communication
Limited Transparency
✗ Few third-party review profiles
✗ No BBB accreditation
✗ Limited online information
Single Storefront
✗ Only one physical location
✗ No national presence
✗ Limited accessibility for non-local customers
Industry Pricing Reality
✗ Wholesale buy offers may disappoint some sellers
✗ Precious metals pricing fluctuates daily
✗ No fixed pricing schedules
PMJ Coins Location, Contact Information & Hours
Address
PMJ Coins & Collectibles
2127 Hillside Ave
New Hyde Park, NY 11040
Phone Numbers
- (516) 869-1030
- (877) 701-0003
Business Hours
| Day | Hours |
|---|---|
| Monday | 9:00 AM – 5:00 PM |
| Tuesday | 9:00 AM – 5:00 PM |
| Wednesday | 9:00 AM – 5:00 PM |
| Thursday | 9:00 AM – 5:00 PM |
| Friday | 9:00 AM – 5:00 PM |
| Saturday | Closed |
| Sunday | Closed |
PMJ Coins vs Augusta Precious Metals vs GoldenCrest Metals vs Goldco
For investors seeking precious metals primarily for wealth preservation or retirement diversification, PMJ Coins differed significantly from Gold IRA specialists.
| Feature | PMJ Coins | Augusta Precious Metals | GoldenCrest Metals | Goldco |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Rare Coins | Excellent | Limited | Limited | Limited |
| Gold IRA Services | No Major Focus | Excellent | Excellent | Excellent |
| Precious Metals Education | Moderate | Excellent | Excellent | Excellent |
| Buyback Program | Available | Strong | Strong | Strong |
| Customer Reviews | Limited | Outstanding | Strong | Outstanding |
| Current Operating Status | Uncertain | Active | Active | Active |
Investors seeking retirement-focused precious metals strategies may find dedicated Gold IRA companies more suitable than a traditional coin dealer.
Is PMJ Coins Legit or a Scam?
Based on available evidence, PMJ Coins appears to have been a legitimate coin dealer rather than a scam.
Several factors support this conclusion:
- Established physical storefront
- Industry memberships
- Professional grading affiliations
- Positive customer reviews
- Long-standing numismatic experience
However, the apparent closure of the business and inaccessible website make it difficult to recommend PMJ Coins to new customers today.
If you are considering purchasing rare coins or precious metals, it may be safer to work with a currently active dealer that offers transparent pricing, strong customer reviews, and ongoing support.
PMJ Coins Review: Final Verdict
After completing this PMJ Coins review, our conclusion is that PMJ Coins was a legitimate rare coin dealer with strong numismatic expertise, professional grading affiliations, and a generally positive reputation among customers.
The company’s strengths included certified coin inventory, coin grading assistance, estate purchasing services, and knowledgeable leadership. However, limited online transparency and reports indicating the business may have permanently closed create uncertainty for prospective customers.
For collectors specifically seeking rare coins, PMJ Coins once offered a solid selection of certified numismatic products. For investors focused on retirement diversification, Gold IRAs, or precious metals wealth preservation, larger and actively operating precious metals firms may offer a more comprehensive solution.
Overall, this PMJ Coins review finds that while the company appeared legitimate during its years of operation, investors and collectors should verify its current status before attempting any transaction.
Frequently Asked Questions
1. Is PMJ Coins still in business?
Reports from Birdeye and the inaccessible company website suggest PMJ Coins may have permanently closed. Prospective customers should verify the company’s current status independently.
2. Who owns PMJ Coins?
PMJ Coins was owned and operated by Marijo Lantier, who served as president of the company.
3. Does PMJ Coins offer coin grading services?
Yes. PMJ Coins reportedly assisted customers with submissions to major grading services such as PCGS, NGC, and NCS.
4. Is PMJ Coins legit?
Based on available evidence, PMJ Coins was a legitimate coin dealer with a physical storefront, industry affiliations, and generally positive customer feedback. However, its current operational status remains uncertain.
Author Profile
- Moses is a precious metals specialist, researcher, and publisher who specializes in reviewing precious metals investment companies. He has spent years analyzing Gold IRA providers, comparing transparency, customer reviews, and fee structures to help investors make informed decisions.
Latest entries
Company ReviewsJune 10, 2026Atlantis Mint Review 2026: Is Atlantis Mint Legit or a Risky Silver Dealer?- Company ReviewsJune 10, 2026Bullion Express Reviews 2026: Is It Legit or a Scam?
- Company ReviewsJune 10, 2026PMJ Coins Review 2026: Is It Legit or a Scam?
- Company ReviewsJune 10, 2026Brink’s Depository Review 2026: Fees, Security, Storage Options, Pros & Cons
