Item: Littleton Coin Company
Rating: 4
Author: Moses

If you’ve searched for Littleton Coin Company reviews, you’ve probably encountered mixed opinions. Some collectors praise the company for its enormous selection of coins, excellent customer service, and beginner-friendly collecting programs. Others criticize its high prices, aggressive marketing tactics, and controversial Coins-on-Approval subscription service.

So, is Littleton Coin Company a legitimate place to buy coins, or should collectors look elsewhere?

In this comprehensive review, we’ll examine Littleton Coin Company’s history, ownership, products, customer feedback, pricing, complaints, and overall reputation to help you determine whether it’s the right choice for your collecting or precious metals investing needs.

What Is Littleton Coin Company?

Littleton Coin Company is one of America’s largest coin dealers and numismatic retailers. Founded in 1945, the company specializes in collectible coins, paper currency, precious metals, and coin collecting supplies.

Headquartered in New Hampshire, Littleton Coin Company has grown from a small mail-order business into a nationally recognized employee-owned company serving hundreds of thousands of collectors.

The company is especially famous for its unique Coins-on-Approval® program, which allows customers to receive coins at home before deciding whether to purchase them.

Key Facts About Littleton Coin Company

Feature	Details
Founded	1945
Headquarters	Littleton, New Hampshire
Ownership	Employee-Owned (ESOP)
Industry	Coins, Bullion & Collectibles
Products	Coins, Currency, Bullion, Supplies
BBB Rating	A+
Physical Store	Yes
Online Store	Yes
Subscription Program	Coins-on-Approval

Who Owns Littleton Coin Company?

Littleton Coin Company was founded by Maynard Sundman and Fannie Sundman in 1945.

In 2017, the Sundman family completed the sale of the company to an Employee Stock Ownership Plan (ESOP), making Littleton Coin Company 100% employee-owned.

Today, David Sundman serves as Chairman, while the company continues to operate from its headquarters in Littleton, New Hampshire.

The employee-owned structure is often viewed positively because it encourages long-term customer service and employee accountability.

Littleton Coin Company Products & Services

Littleton offers one of the largest inventories in the numismatic industry.

1. U.S. Coins

Collectors can find:

Lincoln Cents
Jefferson Nickels
Roosevelt Dimes
Washington Quarters
Morgan Silver Dollars
Peace Dollars
American Eagles
Proof Sets
Mint Sets

2. World Coins

The company carries thousands of international coins from:

Canada
United Kingdom
Australia
Germany
China
Ancient civilizations

3. Paper Currency

Available items include:

U.S. Silver Certificates
Federal Reserve Notes
Obsolete Currency
Foreign Banknotes
Colorized Notes
Historic Currency

4. Gold & Silver Bullion

Bullion products include:

Gold American Eagles
Silver American Eagles
Gold Bars
Silver Bars
Silver Rounds
Precious Metal Collectibles

5. Coin Collecting Supplies

Littleton is particularly respected for its supplies, including:

Coin Albums
Coin Folders
Magnifiers
Storage Boxes
Display Cases
Protective Holders

6. Gifts & Collectibles

The company also sells:

Colorized Coins
Coin Ornaments
Challenge Coins
Historical Replicas
Holiday-Themed Collectibles

Littleton Coin Company’s Coins-on-Approval Program Explained

One of the most discussed topics in many Littleton Coin Company reviews is the Coins-on-Approval program.

Here’s how it works:

Customers order a promotional coin offer.
They are often enrolled into an approval service.
Littleton periodically sends additional coins.
Customers have approximately 15 days to review the items.
They can either:
- Keep and pay for the coins
- Return unwanted items

While some collectors enjoy receiving surprise selections, others find the process inconvenient.

Many complaints online stem from customers who did not fully understand they were joining an ongoing approval program.

Virtual Albums & Collection Management

Littleton offers free digital collection tools that allow collectors to:

Track collections
Monitor missing coins
Build sets online
Earn rewards
Organize inventory

These tools are particularly useful for beginner collectors.

Coin Buying & Appraisal Services

Littleton also purchases:

Rare Coins
Bullion
Gold Coins
Silver Coins
Mint Sets
Collections and Estates

Collectors can submit coins for evaluation through the company.

Littleton Rewards Program

Customers earn points on purchases that can later be redeemed for:

Free Coins
Currency
Coin Supplies
Collecting Accessories

Frequent buyers often find value in the rewards system.

Pros of Littleton Coin Company

Guaranteed Authenticity

Every item undergoes inspection by experienced numismatic professionals.

Massive Product Selection

Few coin dealers can match Littleton’s inventory breadth.

45-Day Satisfaction Guarantee

Customers can return eligible purchases if dissatisfied.

Beginner-Friendly Experience

Educational materials and collecting guides make the hobby accessible.

High-Quality Coin Supplies

Littleton albums and storage products are highly respected among collectors.

Employee-Owned Company

Employee ownership encourages long-term customer-focused operations.

Rewards Program

Regular buyers can accumulate valuable rewards points.

Physical Retail Location

Customers can visit the headquarters store in New Hampshire.

Cons of Littleton Coin Company

Despite its strengths, several drawbacks frequently appear in customer feedback.

1. Higher-Than-Average Prices

The biggest criticism is pricing.

Many coins sell significantly above:

Spot metal value
Auction prices
Local coin shop pricing
Online bullion dealer pricing

Some collectors report paying two to three times market value for common items.

2. Coins-on-Approval Complaints

Many customers dislike automatic enrollment into approval programs.

Common complaints include:

Unexpected mailings
Ongoing subscriptions
Return requirements
Confusing terms

3. Aggressive Marketing

Littleton is known for:

Frequent catalogs
Promotional mailings
Email marketing campaigns

Some customers find these advertisements excessive.

4. Return Shipping Costs

Although returns are allowed, customers generally pay return postage.

5. Shipping Delays

Some reviewers mention delayed shipments during busy periods.

6. Limited Value for Bullion Investors

Investors focused solely on gold and silver often find better pricing elsewhere.

Littleton Coin Company Fees & Pricing

Littleton does not charge membership fees.

However, customers should understand that the company’s pricing model typically includes substantial dealer markups.

Typical Cost Factors

Coin Premiums
Numismatic Markups
Shipping Fees
Sales Tax (where applicable)

Collectors often pay more for the convenience and educational services offered by Littleton.

Littleton Coin Company Reviews & Ratings

To get a balanced look at customer sentiment, we aggregated data across the web’s largest consumer advocate marketplaces.

Review Platform Breakdown

BBB: A+ rated, accredited, 48 complaints closed in the last 3 years.
Trustpilot: 4.4/5 stars based on over 570 reviews.
Google Business: 4.6/5 stars based on 4,463 reviews.
Yelp: 2.1/5 stars based on 87 reviews.
Business Consumer Alliance (BCA) & Trustlink: Not actively listed.

What Real Customers Say

💬 Positive Review: “I ordered several coins and all reasonably priced. Packaged well and Jet fast shipping…. Great Assortment of coins for collectors.” — Google Review

💬 Positive Review: “I was very satisfied! I also got a nice toned Susan B Anthony coupon which I intend to keep. The coin club is great, and the merchandise I ordered was top quality. Thank you Littleton.” — Trustpilot Review

⚠️ Critical Review: “Don’t buy anything from this company! They say they accept returns for 45 days, but that’s only if YOU pay the return shipping. A $25 coin folder I bought cost $33 to return. When I contacted the company, they said, ‘too bad!'” — Yelp Review

⚠️ Critical Review: “First of all I had to wait on the phone for 35 minutes to talk to a salesperson. I ordered a coin on February 3, 2026. Delivery was scheduled for Saturday Feb 7, 2026, which it never showed up… Shipped by UPS and then transferred to USPS, both are lacking in accountability… Totally unacceptable!” — Google Review

Complaints, Lawsuits & Controversies

Our research found no major government enforcement actions or significant lawsuits against Littleton Coin Company.

Most complaints relate to:

Pricing
Marketing practices
Subscription misunderstandings
Shipping delays

These issues appear typical for a large mail-order collectible business rather than indications of fraud.

Is Littleton Coin Company Legit or a Scam?

Littleton Coin Company is 100% legitimate; it is not a scam. They are a real business that has been operating for over 80 years, backed by an A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau. Every coin they ship is guaranteed to be authentic and accurately graded.

The reason some people call them a “scam” online usually stems from a misunderstanding of the Coins-on-Approval fine print. When buyers purchase an introductory promotional item, they often overlook that they are opting into a monthly subscription service. While the sales tactics are aggressive, the company delivers exactly what it promises.

Littleton Coin Company vs Augusta Precious Metals vs Goldco

Feature	Littleton Coin Company	Augusta Precious Metals	Goldco
Founded	1945	2012	2006
Main Focus	Collectible Coins	Gold IRAs	Gold IRAs
Bullion Investing	Yes	Yes	Yes
Gold IRA Services	No	Yes	Yes
Precious Metals Education	Moderate	Excellent	Excellent
Coin Collecting Supplies	Yes	No	No
Best For	Collectors	Retirement Investors	Retirement Investors

Who Should Choose Littleton?

Choose Littleton if you:

Enjoy coin collecting
Need albums and supplies
Like historical currency
Prefer curated collecting programs

Who Should Choose Augusta or Goldco?

Choose Augusta or Goldco if you:

Want a Gold IRA
Need retirement diversification
Focus on bullion investing
Want lower bullion premiums

Read more about Augusta here and Goldco here.

Littleton Coin Company Location, Contacts & Hours

Littleton Coin Company is located in Littleton, New Hampshire.

📍 Location

1309 Mt Eustis Rd
Littleton, NH 03561

📞 Contact & Support

- Toll-Free Phone: 1-800-645-3122 (Available anywhere in the U.S.)
- Email: customerservice@littletoncoin.com
- Support Pages: Customer Support and Online Chat

🕒 Hours of Operation

- Monday – Friday: 9:00 a.m. – 4:00 p.m. ET
- Saturday & Sunday: Closed

(Note: Customer service representatives are available by phone and chat for extended hours, Monday through Friday from 7:30 a.m. to 9:00 p.m. ET)

Littleton Coin Company Reviews: Final Verdict

After examining numerous Littleton Coin Company reviews, we found that the company is a legitimate and well-established coin dealer with a strong reputation for authenticity, customer service, and educational resources.

Its biggest strengths include an enormous inventory, high-quality collecting supplies, a long operating history, and a beginner-friendly approach to coin collecting.

However, prospective buyers should be aware that Littleton frequently charges significantly higher prices than many competing dealers. Additionally, the Coins-on-Approval program remains one of the most controversial aspects of the business and is responsible for many customer complaints.

For casual collectors, hobbyists, and those seeking collecting supplies, Littleton Coin Company can be a useful resource. For investors focused primarily on maximizing precious metals value, comparing prices with other bullion dealers before purchasing is highly recommended.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Littleton Coin Company a reputable company?

Yes. Littleton Coin Company has been operating since 1945 and is generally considered a reputable coin dealer.

Are coins from Littleton Coin Company worth anything?

Yes. The coins are genuine and have collectible and bullion value. However, some buyers believe the company’s prices exceed market value.

Does Littleton Coin Company sell fake coins?

No. Littleton guarantees authenticity and has built its reputation on selling genuine collectible coins.

How does Coins-on-Approval work?

Customers receive coins to examine at home and can either keep and pay for them or return them within the review period.

Can I cancel Littleton Coin Company’s approval service?

Yes. Customers can contact the company to cancel participation in approval programs.

Does Littleton Coin Company buy coins?

Yes. The company purchases collectible coins, bullion, mint sets, and certain collections.

Is Littleton Coin Company good for beginners?

Yes. The company offers educational resources, starter collections, and beginner-friendly collecting tools.

Why is Littleton Coin Company more expensive?

The company’s prices often include premiums that help cover extensive marketing, customer service, inventory management, guarantees, and educational programs.

Does Littleton Coin Company sell gold and silver?

Yes. The company sells gold and silver coins, bars, rounds, and collectible precious metals products.

Does Littleton Coin Company have a physical store?

Yes. Customers can visit the company’s headquarters and retail store in Littleton, New Hampshire.

Author Profile

Moses: Moses is a precious metals specialist, researcher, and publisher who specializes in reviewing precious metals investment companies. He has spent years analyzing Gold IRA providers, comparing transparency, customer reviews, and fee structures to help investors make informed decisions.